For the 80th
anniversary of the Tobruk Easter battle, TSOG ran a re-fight on 26th April
2021. Much of the background and OOB was similar to the 75th anniversary
re-fight in 2016...
TSOG Easter Battles 2016 AAR
Prelude
Elements of
the DAK 5th Light Division (8th MG Battalion [Obserst Ponath], 5th Pz Regt
[Oberst Olbrich]) were ordered by Rommel to breach the Tobruk perimeter at a
perceived weak point on the southern edge, and push through to the port. The
fortress would fall as morale collapsed from the perimeter breach, as had
occurred to Tobruk and Bardia when captured by the Australians a few months
before.
Rommel's
intelligence was minimal to support this attack, with two copies of Italian
maps of the fortifications only made available just before the attack and no
preminary reconnaissance. Allied ships had been seen in the harbour and Rommel
assumed the garrison were evacuating, rather than being re-inforced as was
actually the case, and he could take the fortress 'off the march' as his very
successful first offensive "Sonnenblume" from February had taken him
to the gates of Tobruk.
The attack
fell on the Australian 9th Division, 20th Brigade, 2/17th Battalions [Lt Col
Crawford] sector, particularly B Company (Capt Balfe) in the Red Line at the
outer perimeter, slightly west of the El Adem Road. The preliminaries are well
described in the references [1-4] below. After some probing attacks in previous
days, a breach in the AT ditch was achieved on 12th April between outposts R33
and R35 by 8th MG Battalion, with R33 being overrun.
There were
aggressive night counterattacks by B Company 2/17th, particularly by Lt
Mackells platoon (resulting in a posthumous VC for Cpl Jack Edmonson), driving
8th MG Btn out of R33. This left a bridgehead of line/rifle Kompanies 2 & 3
of 8th MG Battalion exposed in the Red Line between posts R33 and R 35 at the
front, and R32 and R34 at the back. Along this bridgehead before sunrise, the
very reduced strength 5th Pz Regt (I & II battalion, totalling 38 tanks)
drove towards the track at the back of the Red Line with tank riders from 5th
(motorcycle) Kompanie 8th MG Btn and towing some battalion AT guns. Fire from
the outposts drove the tank riders to cover in 'Goschens House' and surrounding
trenches just behind R32, on the north side of the track behind the Red Line.
The 5th Pz
Regt after losing its 5th Kompanie tank riders was reforming to the east of
Goschens House and readying to advance north towardsthe Kings Cross
intersection and Tobruk harbour. They were unaware of the Blue Line of UK and
Australian AT guns blocking their path, which would possibly require the
assistance of 8th MG battalion to clear. They were also unaware of armour, AT
and infantry re-inforcement approaching from both flanks, hurriedly moving into
position in response to the breach of the Red Line.
The 4th
('Schwere' - heavy) Kompanie of 8th MG Btn were taking cover from accurate
rifle fire in the AT ditch to the right of the breach/gap. To the left of the
gap in the AT ditch, or behind it, were the 20mm and 88m AA guns of the 1st
Battalion, 18th Flak Regt, most of their crews shot down by D Company 2/17th
during the night counterattacks and replacement crews lying prone in no-mans
land. Three more Kompanies (1st line/rifle, 7th AT and 6th Pioneers) were
waiting to cross no-mans land, possibly in the face of indirect artillery fire
from 104 RHA behind the Blue Line.
This set
the scene for the engagement near sunrise 0530 on the 13th April 1941, with the
forces intermingled and already in contact as visibility increased.
Game Mechanics
Rule Set = Rapid Fire 2 with local mods.
Scale 1" = 50m,
Each Turn = 30-45 Mins,
1 infantry fig = 15 men, 1 AFV model = 5 AFVs, 1 transport model = 10 vehicles, 1 AT/Arty model = 5 pieces.
Victory conditions depended on the possession of 5 control points (see 2016 AAR) along the line from the AT ditch gap to a point in the Blue Line, heading to Kings Cross. The game commenced with Western Desert Force controlling 3 points and DAK controlling 2, hence a marginal Allied victory.
The DAK were controlled by Pete, Allied Blue Line guns and flanking armour, AT reinforcements by George, and the Red Line Infantry and flanking infantry reinforcements by Maurice, with umpiring by Dave.
The 75th anniversary engagement in 2016 was virtually impossible for the DAK to win with the initial conditions, force mix, allied reinforcement schedule and other variables. So within the bounds of historical possibility and in the light of extra new information [1], some changes were made;
* DAK were given the first move. In the 2016 game, the first turn was diced for and the Allies won, decimating the Kompanies trapped in the Red Line before they fire a shot.
* The 5th Pz Regt did not have to advance to the north in the first two moves without infantry, as Olbrich's actual actions were. So the DAK player could reverse Olbrich's decision and pick up 5th Kompanie for the advance north.
* Historically [Ref 1] the 5th Pz Regt left it's light and command PzKW IIs behind. Hence the PzII models within each battalion were replaced by PzIII (short barrel) and the Regt HQ was placed in the 1st battalion HQ section. Instead of each battalion being composed of a single unit of models, each was composed of 2 Kompanies of two models (~10 vehicles) each. This made the battalions less brittle against morale checks than 2016 (e.g. a heavy damage to one model could force an entire battalion to retreat, but in this game only one Kompanie might retreat).
* From Ref [1] the 8th MG Btn line Kompanies 1,2, & 3 were well supplied with MMGs, light mortars and AT Rifles (i.e. 'all tooled up'). In the 2016 game these were basically just rifle Kompanies with generic small arms capability, and unable to compete in the firefights with the well entrenched outposts and UK armour in the reinforcements, particularly HMG armed MkVI light tanks.
* From Ref [1] , the 5th Kompanie was well supplied with LMGs and hence a had a +2 firing bonus on the die roll. 5th Komp was 3 figures (45 men) down from full strength, having taken considerable losses as tank-riders.
* The bridgehead Kompanies 2 and 3 were not as reduced by the night actions as 2016, being only 2 figures (30 men) down from full strength (8 figures = 120 men).
* Unlike 2016, the 8th MG battalion had the possibility of three additional Kompanies, one per turn, running the gauntlet of artillery fire in no-mans land to reach the gap in the AT ditch.
* The Allied reinforcements on their left flank, 3 squadrons of 1 RTR under Maj Benzies, and B Company AUS 2/3 AT Regt (portee 2 pounders) were forced to enter a bit further north than 2016 and the armour couldn't roll for entry till turn 2. This was to lessen the likelihood that the armour would massacre the 8th MG Kompanie bridgehead in the Red Line as C company MkVIs did in 2016, and which did not occur historically as 1RTR was supposed to engage the panzers.
References
[1] World at War (Strategy & Tactics Press) #64 Feb-Mar 2019, PP16-19.
[2] Desert Siege, by Chester Wilmot, Penguin 1944, Chapter VIII.
[3] Das Afrika Korp, by Franz Kurowski, Stackpole Books 2010, PP44-50.
[4] Tobruk 1941, by Timothy Hall, Octopus 1984, PP68-76.
After Action Report
0530: DAK commenced hostilities with 5th Pz Regt moving immediately "Vorwarts!" as per the historical orders of Olbrich, without waiting to pick up tank riders from 5th Kompanie in Goschen's House. This was to advance towards the victory objective control points in the north as fast as possible, before the line of advance was blocked by Allied reinforcements, which would surely appear soon. The infantry were left to try and keep the gap open to flow through which reinforcements could pass.
Kompanies 2 & 3, lying prone in the gap, commenced a firefight with the outposts in the Red Line, supported by 4th Schwere Kompanie from the AT ditch, with 81cm mortars, 75mm IGs and PaK 36s firing HE, inflicting a few casualties on the well entrenched D company 2/17th. The flak guns were not successfully re-crewed (a common occurrence in the game) as they remained pinned in no-mans land. The reserve 1st Kompanie made it across no-mans land to the entrance of the AT ditch gap.
The Red Line infantry reserves, 2/17 B company, 2/17 Battalion HQ and D Company of the 20 Brigade Reserve 2/15th Battalion, began to move in vehicles towards Goschen's House with the purpose of re-capturing it and pushing the control level to an Allied Substantive Victory early in the game, putting pressure on the DAK to re-capture it, or post R32, or the point in front of the Blue Line.
Artillery spotters in the Rad Line fortifications for off-board 104 RHA 25 pounders began to get the range of targets in the Red Line, AT ditch and no-mans land beyond.
0615: Allied mobile reserves began filtering through the friendly minefields next to the El Adem Road, from the north, the right flank of 5th Panzer Regt. The faster A9 and A10 cruiser tanks of 1 RTR A Squadron, and Mk VIIs of C Squadron were ahead of the slower but more anticipated Matildas of B Squadron. Assistance also came from B Company 2/3 AUS AT Regt with captured Italian 37mm / 47mm guns porteed on trucks. The opening salvoes of a running firefight with 5th Pz Regt commenced. More reinforcement were also appearing from the south, left of 5th Pa Regt, porteed 2pdr AT guns of M battery 3 RHA and captured Italian M13/40 tanks crewed by C Company 2/3 AUS AT Regt. Heavy German fire from the AT ditch caused heavy casualties in posts R35 and R32. R32 was a control point and obvious DAK objective for reserve Kompanie 1/8 as it negotiated the AT ditch into the Red Line. The 88mm and 20mm guns of 1st Bn 18 Flak Regt were unable to be re-crewed by gunners lying prone in no-mans land, luckily for post R33 with Lt Mackell and diggers from D Company 2/17th Btn.
The 25 pounders from the 104 RHA with indirect fire guided by spotters in the Red Line forts, caused the virtual annihilation of 2nd and 3rd Kompanies of 8th MG Battalion as they lay prone in the open in the Red Line.
0700: The Allied infantry reserves from the south dis-embarked from transport outside 300m short range small arms fire from 5th Kompanie in and around Goschen's house and formed up for a close assault. Further reinforcements from the south, C company 2/17th Btn drove north into the Red Line and disembarked to move towards R32 before DAK reinforcements could capture and turn over the control point.
5th Pz Regt moving at full speed and not being delayed by the Allied armour and AT
reinforcements threatening their flanks, had pushed close the un-anticipated AT units and
fortifications of the Blue Line. So far they had not suffered undue losses and had captured
the control point at the rocky outcrop, just short of the Blue Line. Hence 2 Allied control points
(R32, NE corner of Blue Line) vs 3 DAK (AT ditch breach, Goschen’s House, rocky outcrop
just south of Blue Line) made it momentarily an Axis marginal victory.
Allied AT fire from the Blue Line had so far been desultory and ineffective in damaging 5th Pz Regt, and the armour and porteed AT gunbs were not much more effective. The Blue Line had more luck laying suppressing fire on Goschen’s House, softening up 5th Kompanie and 8th MG Btn HQ, for the infantry assault.
0745: After suffering casualties from small arms fire of 5th Kompnaie and 8th MG Btn HQ in Goschen’s House, the D Company 2/15th and B Company 2/17th, backed by Lt Col Crawford’s 2/17 Btn HQ, fixed bayonets and charged. Having numerical superiority, they forced the DAK from the house and surrounding trenches, claiming the control point. So 3 Allied control points to 2 DAK made it momentarily an Allied marginal victory and a very see-saw engagement.
Some light and heavy damage was being cause to 5th Pz Regt by the Allied mobile
armour and AT reserves and a tactical retreat was made from the control point near
the Blue Line, ceding it again the Allies.
0830: The reserves of C Company 2/17th had re-crewed post R32. However, further 8th MG
Btn reserves had filtered through no-man’s land to the breach in the AT ditch, including
the 6th Pioneer Kompanie and they proceeded to assault R32 with flamethrowers causing
heavy casualties but not capturing it and turning over the control point. Forward elements
of 6th Kompanie then began advancing towards Goschen’s House and inflicting casualties with
the flame throwers and small arms fire.
Meanwhile, close to the Blue Line, 5th Pz Regt remnants re-grouped into a tight phalanx and
advanced towards the rocky outcrop control point, re-capturing it, and destroying the unit
of porteed guns of B Company 2/3 AUS AT Regt defending it. However they were being
engaged at short range by 1 RTR cruisers and MkVI tanks and at medium range from the rear
by the delayed Matildas of B Squadron, with significant loss of vehicles. On the left flank of 5th
Pz Regt a long range duel with Allied mobile reserves had not gone well for M Battery 3 RHA
with all their porteed 2 pounders being destroyed and the M13/40 of 2/3 AUS AT Regt sheltering
behind a rocky outcrop.
Play was called on account of the late hour at this point. The Allies held 3 control points (R32 just, Goschen's House possibly about to be captured by 6th Kompanie, and the NE corner of Blue Line) and the DAK held 3 (AT ditch breach and the rocky outcrop just in front just south of the Blue Line) which made the game an Allied marginal victory. However the Axis ended in a stronger position than their historical one, with a mauled 5th Pz Regt poised in front of the Blue Line and not in retreat, and the breach in the Red Line being exploited by 8th MG Btn despite heavy losses to their first wave. If Rommel's famous 'Fingerspuhl' battlefield intuition is working, he may sense a breakthrough and pour more units into the breach.
Fun was had by all...especially the 25Ilber Gun Crews!
Posted by Captain Darling for Oberst Heudegg...
